Why AI-generated financial advice can sound right but still be wrong
It only takes a few seconds to ask AI a financial question. You might want to know whether an ISA is right for you. Perhaps you’re wondering whether you should increase your pension contributions, move an old pension or invest some money you’ve recently received.
Type the question into ChatGPT and you’ll get an answer almost immediately. It can be surprisingly convincing, but that’s why you need to be careful.
A well-written answer can give the impression that the information behind it must be reliable – after all, it’s from AI and it must be correct. But when it comes to financial decisions, sounding confident and being right are two different things.
The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has been looking at how people are using AI for financial information. Its 2026 research found that 56% of 18 to 40 year olds surveyed who owned or were considering investments said they trusted AI tools.
The research also found that 44% believed AI-generated financial information was regulated. More concerningly, 38% thought it was acceptable to make an investment decision based solely on information produced by AI. That last figure is rather worrying, and worth thinking about.
An answer doesn’t have to look wrong to be wrong
One of the things AI does very well is communicate. It can take a complicated subject and turn it into something that’s easy to read. You get a clear response, often with headings, examples and figures. That can make it difficult to spot an error.
The FCA has warned about what it calls AI “hallucinations”. In simple terms, this is when an AI system produces information that sounds plausible but isn’t actually correct. It knows you want an answer and if it can’t find the right details, it basically makes one up. You can read the FCA’s guidance on using AI for investment research.
Imagine you’re asking about a pension rule you don’t know much about. The answer contains the right terminology and appears to explain everything clearly. You may have no reason to question it.
But one figure could be wrong. A condition could have been missed. Or the answer could be based on information that is no longer current.
That’s the problem. If you already knew enough to spot the mistake, you probably wouldn’t have needed to ask the question in the first place.
Financial information has a shelf life
This is particularly relevant in the UK, where tax rules and financial allowances can change, and frequently do.
Pension rules, tax allowances and Investment rules all change. The way a particular product works can also depend on circumstances that aren’t obvious from a short question.
So asking AI, “How much can I put into this?” isn’t necessarily as straightforward as it sounds.
The answer might have been correct at one point. It might even be correct in a general sense. But if you’re making a decision today, you need today’s rules.
The FCA has specifically warned that general-purpose AI tools may not always provide up-to-date information. For anything important, it recommends checking information against reliable sources that aren’t generated by AI.
That could mean checking the FCA, HMRC or GOV.UK before doing anything with your money. It is a small extra step, but potentially an important one.
Your financial situation changes the answer
This is probably the biggest difference between using AI and speaking to a financial adviser.
A financial question rarely exists in isolation.
Take pension transfers as an example.
You might ask:
“Should I transfer my pension?”
AI can explain different pension arrangements and talk through some of the potential advantages and disadvantages.
But what about your particular pension?
Does it have valuable benefits that you could lose by transferring? What other pensions do you have? When do you expect to retire? What income will you need? How much investment risk are you comfortable taking? How would you cope financially if your investments fell in value?
Those questions matter.
The same principle applies to investments, tax planning and retirement planning.
Two people can have the same amount of money and completely different financial priorities.
One might be comfortable taking investment risk because they have a long time before retirement. Another person with exactly the same amount might need access to the money within a few years.
The numbers are the same. The sensible decision may not be.
So, is ChatGPT giving financial advice?
This is where the distinction between information and regulated financial advice becomes important.
ChatGPT and other general-purpose AI systems can provide financial information. That information may be useful. It may also be inaccurate, incomplete or out of date.
The FCA explains that general-purpose AI tools such as ChatGPT and Gemini are not regulated by the FCA in the same way as regulated financial advice provided by an authorised professional.
There is also an important point about consumer protection. The Financial Ombudsman Service and Financial Services Compensation Scheme protections that can apply to regulated financial services do not simply apply because an AI tool has given you an answer.
That doesn’t make AI useless.
If you don’t understand a financial term, AI can be a convenient way of getting a basic explanation. It can help you make sense of a long document or give you a list of questions to take to an adviser.
The danger comes when an explanation starts being treated as a personal recommendation.
How reliable is AI when it comes to money?
There isn’t one number we can use to answer that.
AI might give you an excellent explanation of a simple financial concept and then give you an incomplete answer to a more complicated question.
It also depends on the information available to the system and how current that information is.
But accuracy isn’t the only concern.
Suppose an AI answer is completely accurate. That still doesn’t automatically make it suitable for you.
The FCA’s research recognises that large language models can make complex financial information easier to understand, but their outputs still need to be assessed and considered alongside human judgement.
There is a difference between asking: “What does this pension rule mean?” and asking: “What should I do with my pension?”
The first is mainly an information question. The second is a personal financial decision.
Speak to a regulated financial adviser
AI can be a handy way to get your head around a financial term or to prepare your questions. When it comes to decisions about your pension, investments or tax, though, you need advice that’s based on your circumstances, today’s rules and the accountability of an FCA regulated professional.
At Fairview, we’ve helped people across Essex make confident decisions about their money for a number of years. Whether you’ve got an AI generated answer you’re not sure about, an old pension you’re wondering what to do with, or simply want a second opinion, we’re here to help.
Ready to talk? Contact the team at Fairview to arrange a friendly, no-pressure conversation. We’ll listen, explain things in plain English and help you decide your next step.
